
Deck repair starts with the decking boards, the walking surface, and the joists, the repeated framing underneath. We look at the framing before quoting a few boards. If the joist under a soft spot is soft too, a new board alone will fail, and we tell you that before you spend money on it.
A board replacement swaps soft or split boards and resets popped fasteners. We serve Middletown, Goshen, Warwick, Port Jervis, Chester, Monroe, and Montgomery from the Middletown shop. Free estimate or Call (845) 210-4477.
Repair means replacing what has failed while the structure around it is sound: a run of rotten boards, a soft stair tread, a railing post that rocks, a joist end gone black at the ledger. It is not a facelift. Stain will not glue rotten wood back together, and cleaning does not fix framing. When the damage reaches the main beams, posts, or the house connection, we say rebuild instead and show you why — see new decks for that conversation. When the problem is only the railing or the stairs, those are their own smaller jobs: railings and stairs and landings.
The same local pattern shows up on most repair calls. The shaded side of a deck — usually the north or the side under a maple — never fully dries from May to September, and boards there rot while the sunny side is still solid. Leaf season packs damp litter into the gaps between boards and holds it against the joist tops. Freeze-thaw opens up small checks, surface cracks along the grain, and drives water into them. And on older raised decks around Middletown and Port Jervis, footings poured shallow decades ago have heaved, so the deck rocks and the fasteners work loose. A deck with a spongy feel in one area, boards that compress under a screwdriver, or fasteners spinning in place is telling you where to look.

Call with your town and a short description — photos help, but they do not replace looking underneath. On the visit we probe boards with a screwdriver, open a section if the top feels spongy in a pattern that follows the joists, and check the ledger, posts, and hangers. You get a written estimate that separates board work from framing work, so you can see exactly what each line buys. On work day we pull what is rotten, treat or replace what is under it, set the new boards to match the old as closely as the maker allows, and walk you over the finished section. Keep off the repaired area until everything is secured; we tell you when the boards and stairs are ready for weight.
Deck repair cost depends on how much is soft and how hard it is to reach. A handful of isolated boards over sound framing is a quick job. Softness that follows the joists means framing work, and framing work is priced differently than boards. Height matters — a low platform is easy to get under; a second-story walkout needs staging. Matching a discontinued board profile or an old stain color takes sourcing time. And hidden rot only shows once boards come up, which is why we separate board and framing lines in the estimate instead of blending them into one number. Call for a free written estimate; that is the only honest way to price rot.
It depends on the extent of the soft wood and what is underneath it. A few boards over sound joists is a small job; joists or ledger work adds up differently. We measure and probe on site, then write the estimate — no phone pricing, no per-square-foot guesses.
If the profile and color are still made, yes. If the board is discontinued, we show you the closest match before ordering anything and mark the difference honestly — a near-match in the middle of a deck looks worse than a planned contrast.
Age matters less than what is soft. We have saved decks older than that where only the boards and one railing section had failed, and we have condemned younger decks with a rotten ledger. The screwdriver test on the framing tells the truth; we do the test with you standing there.
“They quoted a run of soft boards, then found two soft joists once the boards came up. It added to the price, but they stopped, showed me the damage, and re-wrote the estimate before doing the work. The shaded side had been spongy for two springs — now it is solid.”
Karen B. · Warwick · Board and joist repair“Honest about what did not need doing. Told us the railings had another five years and just fixed the two stairs treads that were actually soft. Small job, small bill. They will be the first call when the rest of it goes.”
Dan K. · Middletown · Stair tread repairCall with your town and a description of the work. Photos help, but we still look underneath before quoting board replacement. The written estimate sets out materials, scope, and scheduling.
Permit requirements depend on the town and the scope of work. Confirm the requirements with the local building department before construction; discuss responsibility for permits when reviewing the estimate.
Replacement boards need to fit the existing thickness, width, and joist spacing. Capped composite has a plastic shell over a wood-plastic core and may use hidden fasteners, clips that hold boards without exposed screw heads. We check the frame and the board maker’s spacing requirements before switching materials.
If the board is still made, yes. If it is a discontinued groove or color, we say so and show you the closest match before we order anything.
It depends on how much of the deck is soft and what is under the boards. A few isolated boards over sound framing is a small job; soft joists, posts, or a bad ledger connection add structural work. We do not quote exact prices by phone — call (845) 210-4477 for a free written estimate after we look underneath.
Board replacement and repairs to joists or the house connection take different amounts of work. We identify which areas must stay closed and discuss access before removing boards. Keep off the repair area until the boards, rails, and stairs are secured.
No. A soft board does not mean the whole deck is done. We pull what is rotten, check what is under it, and leave the rest if it is solid.
Probe with a screwdriver: soft wood that accepts the blade points at rot. If soft spots are limited to boards, repair usually holds. If the ledger, posts, or many joists are soft, the honest answer is a rebuild, and we show you why on the visit instead of selling patches over a failing frame.
Say that when you call, and we will not ask you to stand on it. We come out, look it over, and tell you the next opening.